Magnet Value Chain: Rare Earths to Motors
Last updated:
The NdFeB magnet value chain spans from separated REE metals through alloy production, magnet manufacturing, and final integration into motors and generators. Each stage adds value and creates bottlenecks. Understanding this chain is essential for evaluating supply risk and investment opportunities.
The Five Stages
1. REE Metal Production
- Separated REE oxides are reduced to metal via calcium or lithium reduction
- Produces high-purity Nd, Pr, Dy, Tb metals
- Capital and expertise intensive
- Limited capacity outside China (10-20% of global)
2. Alloy Production
- REE metals melted with iron and boron in vacuum or inert atmosphere
- Produces NdFeB alloy ingots or powder
- Temperature control critical; contamination ruins batches
- Capex: $50-200M per facility
3. Sintering (Solid-State Pressing)
- Alloy powder pressed and sintered at high temperature
- Creates solid magnet blocks with aligned magnetic domains
- Primary method (~90% of NdFeB magnets)
- High-temperature furnaces required; energy intensive
4. Bonded Magnet Alternative
- Alloy powder mixed with polymer binder
- Injection molded into final magnet shapes
- Lower performance but lower cost
- ~10% of magnet volume; niche applications
5. Integration into Motors
- Magnets assembled into motor rotors and stators
- OEM-level integration with motor control electronics
- EV traction motors: rotor magnets critical to torque delivery
- Wind generators: main shaft magnets enable direct drive
Supply Chain Bottlenecks by Stage
| Stage | China Share | Difficulty | Bottleneck Risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| REE Metals | 70-80% | High | High |
| Alloy Prod | 80-90% | Very High | CRITICAL |
| Sintering | 70-80% | Very High | High |
| Magnet Manuf | 70-85% | Very High | High |
| Motor Integration | 30-50% | Medium | Moderate |
Cost Structure
REE magnet supply chain costs by stage:
- REE metals: 30-40% of final magnet cost
- Alloy production: 10-15%
- Sintering/magnet manuf: 25-35%
- Motor integration: 15-20%
REE input cost dominance means magnet prices spike when REE input prices rise.
Capacity Development
- REE metal plants: Building time 3-5 years; few projects underway outside China
- Alloy plants: Building time 2-4 years; advanced materials knowledge required
- Magnet plants: Building time 18-36 months; faster but still complex
Non-China magnet supply development will lag REE availability through 2030.
Geopolitical Risk in Value Chain
- Every stage has China concentration; no single bottleneck escapes Chinese dominance
- Export controls can target any stage (REE metals, alloys, magnets)
- Western OEMs are vulnerable even if they have magnet capacity (REE metal/alloy risk)
- Diversification requires building entire chain, not just one stage
Investment Opportunities
- REE metal plant developers (rare; extreme technical risk)
- Alloy production capacity (highest bottleneck risk; premium valuation)
- Magnet manufacturers (technology moat; higher margin than upstream)
- OEM integration (Tesla, GE, Vestas benefit from magnet supply bottleneck premium)
Key Takeaways
- NdFeB magnet chain has multiple bottlenecks; no single stage solves scarcity
- China dominates every stage (70-90%); geopolitical leverage is structural
- Capacity building is slow (2-5 years per stage); scarcity persists through 2030+
- REE input costs drive 30-40% of magnet pricing; REE input volatility = magnet volatility
- Integrated producers (mining through magnet manufacturing) command highest margins